Google Wins Major Legal Victory in US Privacy Class Action
In brief · AI summary A federal judge rejected a bid by consumers seeking more than $2 billion in penalties from Google over alleged secret data collection from apps, even after a jury had earlier awarded about $425 million in damages. The judge found that the plaintiffs did not show Google's profits came specifically from the alleged privacy violation, and the class action remains in place covering over 98 million users and 174 million devices. Google has said it plans to appeal the original September verdict.
Google has scored a significant legal win in the United States after a federal judge rejected a bid by consumers seeking more than $2 billion in penalties over the company’s privacy practices.
In a closely watched privacy lawsuit, a group of users accused Google of secretly collecting data from people’s apps even when they believed they had turned off a key privacy setting. A jury last September agreed that Google’s actions violated users’ privacy and awarded about $425 million in damages to the plaintiffs, who had originally asked for $31 billion.
But in the latest twist, the court refused to impose a huge penalty or force Google to give up profits. The consumers had asked the court to order Google to give up about $2.36 billion money they said the company gained from the allegedly unlawful data practices. The judge said the plaintiffs did not provide enough evidence that Google’s profits came specifically from the alleged privacy violation, and that there was no proof of “irreparable harm” that would justify major penalties.
Google argued that forcing it to stop collecting certain data could hurt the wider technology ecosystem. The company said restrictions would harm an analytics service that millions of app developers rely on to understand how users interact with their apps. The judge agreed that the case did not show that users would suffer ongoing harm that required immediate action.
Despite the ruling, Google still faces criticism and ongoing challenges. The judge also denied Google’s request to throw out the class action entirely, meaning the lawsuit involving over 98 million users and 174 million devices remains in place. Google has said it plans to appeal the original September verdict.
For many observers, this case highlights the complexity of privacy disputes in the digital age. The jury’s original decision showed that everyday users are concerned about how their data is collected. But the judge’s recent decision makes it clear that winning a privacy case and winning major financial penalties are two very different things. In practical terms, Google avoids the massive payout — but it still faces legal pressure to defend its practices and respond to user concerns.
Subscribe Deshwale on YouTube